Northumberland Estates’ housing plan in Alnwick rejected
Plans for three new homes in Alnwick have been rejected after the town council raised concerns that it was outside the settlement boundary.
The proposals, put forward by the Duke of Northumberland’s company Northumberland Estates, would have seen the properties built on land south of Greensfield Farm.
The scheme had been recommended for approval by council planners. This was despite the fact Alnwick’s neighbourhood plan, which is currently under review, says the property is outside the settlement boundary.
Because the plan is not yet in force, it could not be given proper weight in the planners’ decision. Despite this, at a meeting of Northumberland County Council’s North Area Planning Committee, members chose to vote down the scheme.


The decision came after Peter Biggers, a planning consultant assisting the town council with the on-going review of its neighbourhood plan, spoke to oppose the plans.
He said: “The town council objected to the proposal and has three major concerns. The principle of development outside the settlement boundary; adverse impact on the landscape; and that permitting development in this area will establish a precedent.
“It is reprehensible that the recommendation before you is to set aside all the work that has been done on the review.”
Emily Andrews, development planners at Northumberland Estates, said: “The development responds to identified local housing need for two and three-bedroom homes in Alnwick.
“The design of the scheme is a particular strength – the proposed homes are 1.5 storey cottages designed to reflect the buildings around them so it sits comfortably beside the existing farmstead. This is a modest development in a sustainable location and all matters have been carefully considered.”
Coun Trevor Thorne initially proposed approval, but was unable to secure a seconder for his motion. He said: “I think it’s a clever development – the fact that the properties are built into the hillside, lessening the that impact and they’re stone and slate.”
Alnwick councillor and chairman of the committee Coun Martin Swinbank proposed refusal, citing a negative impact on the landscape and the setting of the “historic” nearby farmsteads.
He added: “The direction of travel is quite clear. If this had come in a year’s time, it is clear that the officer’s decision may have been different.”
The scheme was rejected by four votes to one.